south perth logo
South Perth Dental Surgery

Invisalign vs Traditional Braces Compared: The Ultimate Showdown

The world of orthodontic treatments is one that may seem complex at first glance, with an array of options available to individuals desiring straighter teeth. Two such options, Invisalign and traditional braces, often stand at the forefront of consideration. While both Invisalign and traditional braces are designed to address misaligned teeth and provide you with a more symmetrical and appealing smile, they differ in various aspects. Understanding these differences is vital for individuals deciding between the two.

The debate surrounding Invisalign vs traditional braces is extensive, with a plethora of factors to consider, such as the nature of orthodontic issues one might be facing, the treatment timeline, and lifestyle implications, among others. Both treatment options have their own set of pros and cons, and their effectiveness varies based on individual circumstances. By exploring the intricacies of each, including everything from the visibility of metal brackets in traditional braces to the flexibility of invisible aligners in Invisalign, one can make an informed decision regarding which method aligns with their unique needs and expectations.

  • Invisalign uses clear, custom-made aligners to gradually shift teeth into position, while traditional braces employ metal or ceramic brackets and wires for tooth movement.

  • Factors influencing the decision between Invisalign and braces include orthodontic issues, lifestyle, aesthetics, and oral hygiene habits.

  • Invisalign is suitable for mild to moderate orthodontic issues, while braces can address a wider range of complex cases.

  • Invisalign offers a more discreet appearance and allows flexibility in eating, but it requires discipline in wearing aligners for at least 20 hours daily.

  • Traditional braces are effective for complex cases but require regular appointments for adjustments and present challenges with certain foods.

  • The cost of Invisalign depends on the complexity, duration, product type, location, clinic pricing, and health fund cover, ranging from \$3,500 to \$9,000 AUD in Australia.

  • Traditional braces’ cost varies based on complexity, duration, braces type, additional appliances, location, and health fund cover, ranging from $4,500 to $8,000 AUD in Australia.

  • Choosing between Invisalign and braces depends on orthodontic issues, treatment plans, daily habits, diet, cost, aesthetics, lifestyle, comfort, and maintenance requirements.
South Perth Dental Surgery

Introduction: Options for Straighter Teeth

Achieving straighter teeth can dramatically enhance one’s self-confidence and improve oral health, but finding the right option can be a challenging endeavour. Two prominent corrective methods—Invisalign and traditional braces—are often at the heart of this difficult decision. These are distinct pathways to a more aligned smile, each with unique characteristics, benefits, and considerations. Invisalign, an innovative approach, uses a series of virtually invisible aligners, custom-made for each patient, to gradually move teeth into their proper positions. On the other hand, traditional braces employ a more conventional system of metal or ceramic brackets and metal wires to address various orthodontic issues.

What is Invisalign?

Invisalign is a contemporary and popular approach to orthodontic care which can offer a more discreet alternative to traditional braces. Using a series of clear, flexible, and custom-made aligners, Invisalign works to adjust the alignment of teeth over time. These aligners are specifically crafted to apply targeted pressure to the teeth that need repositioning, gently guiding them into the desired location over the course of the treatment.

The treatment commences with an initial consultation at a dental clinic where the patient’s teeth are scanned to create a precise 3D digital model. This model serves as the blueprint for the bespoke aligners and the individual’s treatment plan. Throughout the course of the treatment, the aligners are replaced every one to two weeks to accommodate the gradual shift in the positioning of the teeth. This type of treatment is especially suitable for teenagers and adults with mild to moderate orthodontic issues such as overbite, underbite, crossbite, gaps between teeth, and overcrowded teeth. However, it is essential to remember that every individual’s needs and circumstances are unique, and what works for one individual person may not be the ideal choice for another. Therefore, a thorough assessment per patient and consultation with the dental clinic is necessary to decide between Invisalign and traditional braces, ensuring the best possible outcome for the patient.

South Perth Dental Surgery

What are Traditional Braces?

Traditional braces, often referred to as metal braces or ceramic braces, are a commonly utilised method for addressing orthodontic issues. They consist of small brackets, typically made from metal or ceramic materials, that are affixed to each tooth’s surface. A wire, often referred to as an arch wire, threads through these brackets. This wire is periodically tightened during regular appointments at the dental clinic, applying consistent and controlled pressure to the teeth. This pressure gradually guides the teeth towards a more aligned position, addressing crooked teeth, gaps, and various bite issues.

This type of treatment is extremely versatile, able to manage a wide range of orthodontic issues from the simple to the complex. Thus, traditional braces can be an effective option for a broad spectrum of patients, including those with severe alignment issues or overcrowding of teeth. However, depending on the case, they may require a longer duration of treatment compared to other options like Invisalign. In terms of aesthetics, metal braces are more noticeable compared to aligners with a near-invisible appearance, while ceramic braces offer a more discreet appearance due to their colour, which typically matches the colour of the teeth. Though traditional braces may pose challenges with certain types of foods, particularly sticky and chewy foods that can get caught in the brackets and wires, they do not require removal for eating as is necessary with Invisalign aligners. Regardless, maintaining good brushing habits is vital with traditional braces so that plaque does not lead to gum disease or bad breath.

Invisalign vs Traditional Braces: The Cost Factor

Invisalign

While considering orthodontic treatments to achieve a straighter smile, cost is often a critical factor. When comparing Invisalign and traditional braces, it’s essential to understand the factors influencing the cost of Invisalign treatment.

  1. Complexity of the Orthodontic Issues:
    The severity and complexity of the orthodontic problems being managed can significantly influence the cost of the treatment. More complex cases require a longer duration of treatment, and hence, more Invisalign aligners, leading to increased costs. Issues like crooked teeth, misaligned teeth, or bite issues are common orthodontic issues that can be addressed using Invisalign1.

  2. Duration of Treatment:
    The longer the treatment plan, the more aligners needed, which can increase the cost. The average treatment time for Invisalign is around 12 to 18 months, but it can extend beyond this depending on the orthodontic issues being addressed2.

  3. Type of Invisalign Product:
    There are various types of Invisalign products designed for different needs and age groups, such as Invisalign Full, Invisalign Teen, or Invisalign Express. Each product varies in cost.

  4. Geographical Location:
    The region where you are seeking treatment can influence the cost, due to critical differences in living costs and operational costs of the clinics.

  5. Clinic’s Pricing Structure:
    Every dental clinic has a different pricing structure. Some may offer payment plans or have certain policies that could affect the overall cost.

  6. Health Fund Cover:
    Depending on the patient’s health fund, a portion of the cost of Invisalign may be covered, but this varies widely from fund to fund.


In Australia, the general cost range for Invisalign treatment can vary anywhere from $3,500 to $9,000 AUD. However, this price is an estimate only, and it can vary significantly based on the factors mentioned above. It’s always best to discuss the cost with your chosen clinic to get an accurate quote.


Traditional Braces

Traditional braces, commonly referred to as metal braces or conventional braces, have been around for quite some time. They are a tested and tried method to manage a multitude of orthodontic issues, from crooked teeth to misaligned bites. In the conversation of “Invisalign vs traditional braces”, understanding the cost factor associated with each is crucial.

  1. Orthodontic Treatment Complexity:
    The complexity of the patient’s orthodontic issues greatly influences the cost of traditional braces. If a patient has severely misaligned teeth or complicated correct bite issues, it would necessitate a more involved and, thus, more costly treatment plan.

  2. Duration of Treatment:
    How long a patient requires braces also affects the cost. A shorter treatment duration could reduce the cost compared to a long-term treatment plan. The average treatment time is usually between 18 to 24 months, but it can be more or less depending on individual orthodontic issues.

  3. Type of Braces Chosen:
    There are different types of traditional braces people get to choose from, each coming with a different price tag. Standard metal braces are usually the most affordable, while ceramic braces, self-ligating braces, and lingual braces (braces attached to the back of the teeth) are generally more expensive due to their materials and the added comfort or aesthetic appeal they offer.

  4. Additional Orthodontic Appliances:
    Certain orthodontic issues may require additional appliances like spacers, expanders, or retainers, which can add to the overall cost of the treatment.

  5. Geographical Location:
    The cost of braces can vary from one location to another within Australia. Typically, cities and regions with higher costs of living may also have higher orthodontic costs.

  6. Health Fund Benefits:
    The extent to which a health fund will cover for orthodontic treatments can greatly impact out-of-pocket costs. Some funds may offer substantial benefits for orthodontic work, while others might offer less generous cover. It’s essential to check with your health fund to understand what is covered and what isn’t.


As per the Australian Society of Orthodontics, the cost for traditional braces typically ranges from $4,500 to $8,000, but prices can vary. Factors such as the ones mentioned above all contribute to the final price. Choosing between Invisalign and braces thus involves a careful evaluation of these factors to make a knowledgeable decision. It is important to have a detailed consultation with an ethical dentist to get an accurate quote based on your individual orthodontic needs and treatment options.

Effectiveness: Invisalign vs Traditional Braces

Traditional types of braces, including types like metal braces and ceramic braces, have been the mainstay for decades and continue to be an effective orthodontic treatment option for a range of orthodontic issues. From minor misalignments to severe malocclusions, traditional braces are capable of addressing complex cases, including significant crooked teeth, crowded teeth, and issues with a person’s bite. They function through the use of traditional metal brackets and wires to apply constant pressure to teeth, gradually moving them into the desired positions. Regular appointments with your dentist so proper adjustments are made to keep your treatment plan on track. However, one aspect to consider is the cons of braces; the presence of metal brackets can complicate oral hygiene, potentially trapping food particles and increasing the risk of gum disease if brushing habits are not maintained.

On the other hand, Invisalign, an increasingly popular treatment option, employs a series of clear, invisible aligners to adjust tooth movements. These aligners are custom-made for each patient and are designed to gradually shift teeth into their proper positions. Invisalign aligners are well-suited to address mild to moderate orthodontic issues, including minor crooked teeth and some bite irregularities. Some of the pros of Invisalign include their discreet appearance, allowing users to work on their confident smiles without the obvious presence of dental braces. They also remove dietary restrictions associated with traditional braces, as the aligners can be removed during meals. Nevertheless, it is essential to keep in mind that Invisalign requires the wearer to maintain discipline, as the aligners must be worn for at least 20-plus hours per day for effective treatment. In cases of severe malocclusions, Invisalign may not be the ideal treatment type.

Comfort and Convenience: Invisalign vs Traditional Braces

When examining the comfort and convenience of Invisalign and traditional braces, there are several factors to consider. Here, we look at how they stack up against each other.

Appearance

  • Invisalign:
    Invisalign aligners are designed with a discreet appearance in mind. They’re made from clear, flexible material that makes them nearly invisible when worn, which can be particularly appealing to adult patients and self-conscious teens. This “invisible” nature of Invisalign can potentially lead to higher confidence levels in social situations.

  • Traditional Metal Braces:
    Traditional metal braces involve metal brackets and wires attached to the teeth, which are quite noticeable. While advancements have led to smaller and less conspicuous designs, and while options such as ceramic braces are available to somewhat blend with the tooth colour, they’re still more visible compared to Invisalign.



Maintenance

  • Invisalign:
    Invisalign aligners require careful maintenance. They need to be removed before eating or drinking anything but water to avoid staining, and you must clean your teeth before putting the aligners back in to prevent trapping food particles which could lead to bad breath or gum disease. Cleaning the aligners themselves is also important and involves brushing them gently and rinsing them in lukewarm water.

  • Traditional Metal Braces:
    Metal braces require a bit extra care in terms of maintenance. Food restrictions are necessary to prevent damaging the brackets and wires. Sticky or hard foods could get trapped in the braces, making cleaning more of a task. Regular appointments are also necessary for adjustments and check-ups.



Lifestyle Impact

  • Invisalign:
    Invisalign aligners can be removed for up to 2 hours per day, which provides flexibility for eating, brushing, and flossing. However, this flexibility requires self-discipline to ensure the aligners are worn for the recommended 20-22 hours per day for effective treatment. Some individuals may also find the need to remove and clean the aligners before and after each meal inconvenient.

  • Traditional Metal Braces:
    Once traditional braces are fitted, they stay in place until the treatment is completed, meaning there are no worries about forgetting to put them back in. But the presence of dental braces does mean you’ll need to adjust your brushing habits to ensure thorough cleaning around the brackets and wires. Some people may also experience discomfort from the pressure applied to the teeth and from adjustments during regular appointments.

Duration of Treatment: Invisalign vs Traditional Braces

The “Invisalign vs Traditional Braces” debate involves many factors, including the duration of treatment, which can be influenced by a variety of aspects. Traditional metal braces, for instance, are generally worn for about 18 to 24 months. This timeline, however, is contingent upon the complexity of the orthodontic issues that need addressing, such as crooked teeth or bite discrepancies. The prolonged duration of treatment with braces can necessitate regular appointments for adjustments, which can add to the overall commitment associated with this treatment type.

Contrarily, Invisalign, a popular alternative to braces, typically demands a shorter average treatment time of around 12 to 18 months. However, the success of this treatment option rests largely on patient compliance. The invisible aligners must be worn for at least 20 to 22 hours per day to ensure effective treatment; less than this can lengthen the treatment duration. Another pro of Invisalign is that the aligners are swapped every fortnight, and progress is tracked digitally, leading to fewer visits to the dental clinic in comparison to traditional braces.

Both treatment plans share the aspect that the duration of treatment can be influenced by a patient’s oral hygiene. Both Invisalign and braces demand conscientious brushing habits and thorough flossing to avert issues such as gum disease that can potentially extend the treatment time. Likewise, dietary habits, such as frequently eating chewy foods or failing to dislodge bits of food trapped in braces, can impact the treatment timeline.

Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider

When choosing between Invisalign and traditional braces, several factors come into play. Here are some aspects to consider:

  1. Orthodontic Issues:
    If you’re dealing with simple orthodontic issues such as slightly crooked teeth or mild misalignment, invisible aligners may be an appropriate treatment option. For more complex issues involving severe movement of teeth, traditional metal braces or ceramic braces might be recommended.

  2. Treatment Plans:
    The duration of treatment varies between Invisalign and metal braces. Typically, traditional metal braces require longer treatment times compared to Invisalign. However, the treatment time for both depends on the individual’s orthodontic issues and how often the treatment option is utilised.

  3. Daily Habits:
    The choice between Invisalign and braces will affect your daily life. Invisible aligners demand a commitment of 20-22 hours per day and the flexibility to remove them when eating or brushing. On the other hand, braces need a meticulous dental care process to prevent food particles from getting stuck in the metal brackets, which could lead to issues like bad breath and gum disease.

  4. Diet:
    With Invisalign, there are fewer restrictions, as you can remove the aligners when eating. Braces, however, might limit the consumption of sticky foods and chewy foods.

  5. Cost:
    The cost of braces or Invisalign is an important factor. The cost varies greatly, depending on the type of treatment needed. Consultation with a dental professional can provide a better understanding of the costs involved.

  6. Aesthetics:
    If a discreet appearance is a high priority for you, Invisalign might be the preferred choice due to its clear, almost invisible trays. Traditional braces, including ceramic and lingual braces, are more noticeable.

  7. Lifestyle and Comfort:
    Some may find Invisalign more comfortable because of the absence of metal brackets and wires. They are also more compatible with an active lifestyle. In contrast, braces, especially metal braces, might cause some degrees of discomfort initially.

  8. Maintenance:
    Proper oral hygiene is critical with both options. Regular adjustment appointments with your dental professional are crucial to ensure the effectiveness of the treatment. Daily brushing time and habits need to be rigorous to prevent gum disease, and flossing is also important.

Final Thoughts

As we’ve unpacked the comparison of Invisalign vs traditional braces, it’s clear that both offer their own unique advantages and drawbacks. The choice between the two relies heavily on individual needs and circumstances. Remember, Invisalign offers a discreet, removable, and more comfortable option for addressing orthodontic issues. However, it also requires strict compliance with the advised wear time and might not manage more complex dental irregularities as effectively as traditional braces.

On the flip side, traditional braces, though they can be visually prominent and come with some dietary restrictions, are a powerful tool for tackling a wide range of complex orthodontic problems. They are worn continuously and don’t rely on the patient remembering to put them back in after eating or brushing. The pros and cons of traditional braces and Invisalign should be thoroughly evaluated in light of your individual dental health, lifestyle, and personal preferences.

Ultimately, your decision in choosing between Invisalign and braces should be made in consultation with a dental professional. South Perth Dental Surgery is dedicated to helping you navigate these decisions and find a treatment plan that best suits your needs. Our team understands that orthodontic care is a significant commitment, and we’re here to provide you with the information and support you need. Reach out to us to schedule a consultation and start your journey towards a healthier, incredible smile.

Call Us Today to Schedule Your Dental Appointment

South Perth Dental Surgery has been providing high-quality dental care to families for over 30 years. Our team of experienced dentists offer extensive world-class services and stays current with the latest dental technology so we can help keep your smile looking great.
 
Make an appointment with us today and see what we have to offer!